Home » CHyCle » discussions

Conference Discussions

This conference is organized by Raquel Nieto. Sciforum is not responsible for the content posted on this website.
Shortcuts

Paper Comments

Re: CLLJ and other patterns
About zonal part of PKE, for Figure 1 zonal PKE appears to represent the two main guides o...
Re: tangential questions
Hi Teddy We didn’t have in account the SST on the analysis, we focused our analysis on the...
Comment!
Dear authors! It is an interesting work!!!. Just to comment something; despite the low c...
Re: CLLJ and other patterns
Thank you Teddy for your comments. Yes, CLLJ is a key feature in explaining Climate dynam...
Re: scales of quasi-stationary circulations
Hello Ana There are some suggestion on the mechanisms that connect the Intra Americas Seas...
Re: data period
Dear Dr. Raquel Nieto, The data period is a constraint from the ERA Interim Land. This re...
Re: change the forest to grass
Dear authors, congratulations for the work! Agreeing with Raquel, it will be very interes...
mean and transients
Hi Teddy, Very nice study! Does your study imply that the transients related to baroclini...
data period
This is an interesting work and the authors explain it with detail. I have only a question...
change the forest to grass
Dear Marta, do you think that it could be interesting know which is the effect of the sur...
Figure 2 correlations
Thank you for sharing this very interesting study. Two quick points. 1. In Figure 2, is t...
precipitable water vapor
Have you consider to directly use a forecasting scheme based on Suominet integrated precip...
Re: other earlier moisture sources? Panama Low?
Hi Ted! Not directly for this work but we have checked on the low system as a possible pre...
Re: scales of quasi-stationary circulations
Hi!. I think it sure does, still the moisture export signature contains a lot of noise whi...
Re: monsoon onset dates
You are right, that was not explicitly mentioned, since different from other monsoon syste...
Re: Mediterranean Sea anomaly
Dear Diego, Thank you very much for the comment. We will extend this analysis. Moisture a...
Re: Iber
Dear Dr Nieto, thanks for your question. Iber is a numerical code with a wide range of...
Re: August and October results
Dear Marta, Thank you so much for the comment. The results showed the similar pattern fo...
Re: Streamflow data
Dear Marta, thanks for your comment. We considered the series having less than 10% of dat...
Mediterranean Sea anomaly
Dear authors, I read the contribution and found it very insightful. I believe there are m...
tangential questions
Thank you for sharing your work. I have just a few questions. 1) The summer peak in CLLJ i...
Re: CLLJ and other patterns
Upon further thought....what would happen if you only used the zonal part of the KPE equat...
Re: Validation of EPEs and rankings
Dear Margarida, I will look up the events that fall at the top 1% of the distribution. Th...
Re: COLs in Iberian Peninsula
Thank you Raquel, I looked at daily maps of rainfall, winds, temperature and geopotential...
Re: the role of transients
Please accept a correction in the above comment: The jet streaks associated with winter t...
CLLJ and other patterns
Like you, I am fascinated by the role of the CLLJ in regional summer rainfall dynamics. Ho...
other earlier moisture sources? Panama Low?
Hi Ana! I know you focus here on the NAM during the summer, but did you do any moisture an...
Re: the role of transients
We simplify precipitation ingredients into two parts: uplift dynamics and moisture source....
Re: data
Yes Raquel, that is right, thank you for observation. Horizontal resolution for NCEP is 2....
scales of quasi-stationary circulations
Is it possible that the role of the Gulf of California moisture flow be modulated by a lar...
the role of transients
What is the role of the mid latitude cyclones in the formation of the Caribbean rain belt,...
Validation of EPEs and rankings
Dear Rosana I really enjoyed reading your article, as it complements the research on extr...
Re: Table 1
Dear Marta Thanks for your interest. The correlations are statistically significant at t...
data
This an interesting work, my question is about the data, Why the periods are different? ...
RLs values over Iberia
Dear Authors, I enjoyed reading your work, as I am also interested in the return levels (...
Re: floods and archeological sites
Dear Dr. Nieto, thank for your comment! The preservation of the cultural heritage, in my...
Table 1
Dear authors, Cogratulation for the interesting work. My question concers Table 1, are th...
Streamflow data
Dear authors, It is a very interesting work. My question concerns the streamflow data. In...
monsoon onset dates
Interesting work. However, it is not clearly pointed out how the monsoon onset dates are e...
August and October results
Dear authors, It is a very interesting paper. From the text I extract that, despite only ...
Re: "Monsoon" related variability
Thank you very much. We are looking for robustness and consistency throughout our region o...
Comment!
Dear Authors! This work is very interesting and can be used to make disaster reduction p...
floods and archeological sites
Congratulations for this application. It is really interesting the possibilities of this m...
Re: Comment!
Dear Rogert, Thank you so much for the sugestion. We will consider it in the future. Kin...
Iber
Congratulations for the implementation of this model. My question is: what is the improve...
Re: defining the target area
Thanks for the comment, of course the SIE changes month by month. For the backward experim...
Re: Spatial orientation
Dear Dr. Trigo, Thank you for your comment. We agree and some examples of real ARs crossi...
Re: return period of the event
Dear Sergio, Thank you for your comment and the interest in our publication. We did not ...
Re: Comments
Thanks for your interest, We have applied SPI because most of the stations have not the v...
Methodology
Dear Authors, This is a very interesting research topic. My comment is on the technical ...
defining the target area
Dear authors, congratulations! Just one question, please. For each region individually, ...
Re: Nice work
Dear Danica, Thank you so much for the sugestion. It definitely would improve the article...
Spatial orientation
Dear Authors I enjoyed your work but have some difficulty visualizing the orientaton of t...
Comments
Dear authors, Thank you for participating in this conference! It is a very nice work that...
moisture source relationship
The issue you pursue in this study is very interesting, my only doubt is that if the taggi...
Re: RNF comments
Thank you for your interest in our work and for the careful revision and comments. Some de...
Re: maps of ARs frequency
Dear Raquel, Unfortunately we do not have access to all the reanalysis IVT. We work dir...
Comment!
Dear authors ! I consider it is an interesting paper and your approach like a new method...
Re: variability and ITCZ over the Pacific
Hi Ana Durán, Thanks for your comment and interest in our paper. We highly appreciate it. ...
ATM x CPLD
Hello Anita, - Yes, that is correct. AGCM = ATM. - Yes, that is correct again: monthly cl...
about the experiment ATM
Dear authors, Firstly, thank you very much for your participation in this conference. Pl...
microsoft edge password manager
Microsoft Edge browser allows users to save passwords for the websites or application regu...
Nice work
Dear authors, I would like to say that you made very interesting study of moisture sources...
Re: Methodology
Dear Michelle, Thanks so much for your words and comments. The evolution was determined ...
RNF comments
This is a very timely and relevant study of the comparison of TRMM and raingauges in the I...
Methodology
Dear authors, I found very interesting your work. I would like to know more details about ...
Winds
Including a more robust analysis of the diurnal cycle of the winds would be a great input,...
Evaluation of the method
This a problem that has been around for a long time without a formal solution, hope your w...
"Monsoon" related variability
This is a good contribution, I wonder why the effect of ENSO on the so called North Americ...
COLs in Iberian Peninsula
This work presents a climatology of COLs over a region where these systems are really impo...
maps of ARs frequency
This work is based on an intense computation using four datasets to detect ARs on the Euro...
precipitation
Nice work! For a future publication: Do you have the possibility of extending the analyz...
interesting work
This is a very interesting proceeding, and it will a really good paper on comparig methodo...
Re: Comments
Dear Dr. Germán, Thank you for your comments and suggestions !. We will take them into a...
Comments
Dear Authors: Congratulation on an interesting paper. I have the following comments: 1) ...
Re: Two questions
Dear German, thanks a lot for your comments. We did not tested the suitability of log-lo...
variability and ITCZ over the Pacific
Would you link the obtained results regarding the year to year variability for the Pacific...
Two questions
Dear Authors: 1) Does the log-logistic distribution for ED arise from the same kind of di...
Re: Drought indices
Dear Sergio Thank you for your comments. In fact, we have already calculated SPI to quant...
Specific Comments
Dear Authors: I have the following questions/comments on your presentation: 1) Regarding...
Statistical Tests
Dear Authors: Your results would greatly benefit from more rigorous statistical tests reg...
Specific Commets
Dear Authors: Thank you very much for your contribution to the Conference. This topic is ...
Drought indices
Dear authors, thank you very much for your interesting contribution. My question is relat...
return period of the event
Dear authors, thank you very much for the manuscript. I wonder if you have calculated the...
correlation
Dear authors, My question concerns the Table 4. Have you applied a test of statistical si...
Sponsors