Monkey orange (Strychnos spinosa Lam.) is an underutilised indigenous fruit of the Loganiaceae family with considerable nutritional and phytochemical potential; however, its intraspecific morphological and metabolomic diversity remains poorly characterised. This study integrated morphological characterisation, physicochemical analysis, phytochemical quantification, antioxidant assays, and untargeted ultra-performance liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (UPLC-MS) metabolomics to characterise 32 S. spinosa fruit accessions and elucidate morphotype-specific compositional signatures and trait–metabolite associations. Multivariate analysis resolved three distinct morphotype groups with differentiated physicochemical and metabolomic profiles. Large pyriform fruits (1103-1328 g) were characterised by elevated carotenoid content (632.50 mg β-carotene/100 g) and lipid-enriched metabolomic profiles dominated by putatively annotated phosphatidylcholines. Small, roundish purple fruits exhibited comparatively high titratable acidity (1.20-1.83%) and total phenolic content (3.72 mg GAE/g), accompanied by strong antioxidant activity (DPPH: 1.82 μmol TE/g), with total phenolic content positively correlated with DPPH antioxidant activity (r = 0.65). Smooth green fruits displayed a comparatively balanced total soluble solids (14-16 °Brix) and titratable acidity (1.50-1.80%) profile together with diverse metabolite features. Principal component analysis further differentiated the accessions, with separation along PC1 associated predominantly with features putatively annotated as phosphatidylcholines at mass-to-charge ratios (m/z) 596.40125 and 814.56787 and a triterpenoid-related feature at m/z 377.19971. PC2, accounting for 21.7% of the variance, provided additional discrimination, with features at m/z 550.39569 and 586.37256 contributing positively to group separation. Overall, phosphatidylcholine-related features were important discriminants between purple- and green-fruited accessions, whereas the triterpenoid-related feature contributed to differentiation of Group 3. Accessions exhibiting favourable combinations of morphological, physicochemical, antioxidant, and metabolomic traits, particularly PRR-dGRO and GRP-GEO accessions and folded-leaf morphotypes, represent promising candidates for germplasm selection, domestication, breeding, and development of value-added functional food products. These findings provide new evidence of substantial intraspecific phenotypic and chemical diversity within S. spinosa and establish a trait–metabolite framework for selecting superior germplasm for future utilisation and improvement programmes.