The electromechanical impedance (EMI) method has been extensively studied for damage detection in structural health monitoring (SHM). The method uses piezoelectric transducers to measure the electromechanical impedance and, as is well known, is highly sensitive to temperature, which alters the properties of both the monitored structure and the transducer. The effects of temperature have been extensively studied in recent years. Studies reported in the literature typically conduct experimental analyses with test specimens under uniform temperature distribution obtained using controlled chambers. However, in real-world applications where the environment is not controlled, the monitored structure may exhibit a non-uniform temperature distribution. Therefore, this paper presents a comparative experimental analysis of the impacts of uniform and non-uniform temperature distributions on the monitored structure. Tests were conducted on a carbon fiber-reinforced polymers (CFRP) plate as a test specimen under different temperature distributions. The test specimen was heated using a heat gun, and the temperature distribution was measured and controlled with a thermal camera. A piezoelectric transducer was attached to the test specimen, and the electromechanical impedance was obtained using a measurement system based on a data acquisition (DAQ) device. The effects of uniform and non-uniform temperature distributions were analyzed by observing the impedance signatures and quantified using damage indices. The results show that non-uniform temperature distribution can reduce the effectiveness of compensation techniques and hinder the correct diagnosis of the monitored structure.