Introduction: A wide variety of mobile intervertebral disc prostheses are commercially available or patented. Despite numerous review articles, a classification based on mechanical principles and a detailed kinematic and static evaluation of these endoprostheses are lacking. This diversity suggests that natural disc mechanics are not fully understood and existing replacement systems remain insufficiently investigated.
Methods: Prostheses were classified by common design features identified from products, literature, and patents. Kinematics were assessed based on centres of rotation (CR) determined from drawings, radiographs, and calculations. Statics were analysed using free-body diagrams.
Results and Discussion: Disc replacement systems were classified into: 1) Joint types (featuring a specific physical joint—e.g., revolute, prismatic, planar, or spherical—and defined degrees of freedom); 2) Sandwich types (elastic, spring-based, fluid-filled, or combinations); and 3) Hybrid types (combinations of joint and sandwich types). Kinematic classification compared the implant CR with the physiological CR (typically within the inferior vertebral body). In constrained sandwich (e.g., Acroflex) and inverted spherical (Prestige Disc) implants, the CR lies in the middle of the replaced disc. Conversely, constrained joint types with one (ProDisc) or two (Charité) joints exhibit a fixed CR within the inferior vertebral body. Unconstrained implants with a mobile CR require a combination of spherical and planar joints in series (Mobi-Disc). Static analysis shows that unconstrained implants transmit lower shear forces to the bone (via osseointegration or screws), facet joints, and ligaments, reducing risks of bone-implant interface failure and facet joint degeneration.
Conclusions: Restoration of the physiological CR and reduction of shear forces depend significantly on the underlying design, with unconstrained designs achieving the best results.