Ship recycling is hazardous. Existing methods focus on hazards and compliance, with limited capacity to reconstruct accident pathways or evaluate frontline adaptations. COSIFSR integrates HFACS-SR, the Systemic Occurrence Analysis Methodology (SOAM), and safety-gated analysis of adaptive practices. HFACS-SR was applied to 50 unique cases screened from 794 NGO Shipbreaking Platform records, covering Bangladesh (27), India (3), Pakistan (4), and Türkiye (16) from 2009 to 2023. Two coders independently applied conventional HFACS and the 53-code HFACS-SR taxonomy, producing Cohen’s κ = 0.71. Only directly evidenced and strongly rule-based inferred factors entered the primary analysis. Six information-rich cases, one from each hazard type, were selected for SOAM analysis, which identified 31 distinct absent or failed barriers.
Safety-II analysis used 1,830 supervisor-recorded events from Nigeria (1,370), India (240), and Indonesia (220). Independent review agreed on 1,820 classifications; ten disagreements were adjudicated (κ = 0.970). The records produced 58 practices assessed using RAG and a safety-gated Practice Evidence Score. Route agreement was κ = 0.793; 39 practices were classified as bounded, 17 as conditional, and two as unsafe. Ten of 31 barriers were fully covered, seven partially covered, and 14 uncovered, producing full and weighted Barrier Coverage Indices of 32.3% and 43.5%.
In Nigeria, escalated or unresolved outcomes decreased from 27/480 (5.62%) to 12/540 (2.22%), an absolute reduction of 3.40 percentage points and a relative reduction of 60.5%. Since delayed-adoption Lagos also improved before implementation, this non-randomised four-yard result is descriptive, not causal. Among 138 matched workers, supervisory support and formal recognition increased by 14.86 and 20.92 percentage points but not significantly more in early-adoption yards than in Lagos.
COSIFSR supports facility-level accident learning and corrective-action prioritisation under the Hong Kong Convention but does not replace regulatory compliance, certified controls, atmospheric testing, permits, PPE, or medical and emergency provision.