This study evaluates the 20-year fatigue life of a small vessel operating in the Mediterranean Sea by comparing three shipbuilding materials: AA5083 aluminum alloy, S355 steel, and Ti6Al4V titanium alloy. Fatigue damage was assessed using the Palmgren–Miner rule and S–N curves based on known material properties, considering the same geometry and structural configuration. Stress histories were derived from wave-induced vertical bending moments through hydrodynamic simulations. Among the materials, AA5083 proved to be the most critical, showing the highest sensitivity to cyclic loading. The analysis was extended to the extreme marine event Cyclone Harry, which generated significant wave heights up to 6 m and maximum wave heights of approximately 10 m along the coasts of Sicily. Two wave directions were considered: 105°, based on measurements from the ISPRA buoy off the coast of Catania, and 180° (head sea), identified as the most critical condition in the literature. Regular and irregular waves were compared under equivalent wave height and period conditions, and the predicted bending moments were compared with the DNV allowable hogging moment. At 16 knots, the DNV allowable bending moment was exceeded at a significant wave height of 2.0 m for 105°, while the 180° condition approached the allowable limit at approximately 1.5 m. Fatigue damage was assessed using the buoy measurements, with each 30 minutes recording extended according to the corresponding sea-state exposure duration. Cumulative damage reached 5.78 for 105° and 10.74 for 180° at 16 knots, while Miner unit damage threshold reached after approximately 21 and 16.5 hours, respectively. These results highlight the importance of wave direction, vessel speed, and marine event intensity and duration.