Barrier islands exhibit diverse dune morphologies, ranging from high and stable dune systems to low and transitional states, reflecting differences in their ability to accumulate and retain sediment under changing environmental conditions. However, the processes controlling these contrasting states across barrier island systems remain poorly constrained. This study investigates why Dutch barrier islands of the Wadden Sea and US barrier islands, such as the Outer Banks of North Carolina, develop contrasting dune states, focusing on the combined influence of sediment availability, storminess, and vegetation dynamics.
Building upon the Dune-ing it Right one-dimensional numerical model, this study extends the framework to simulate sandy barrier island evolution over decadal timescales. The model couples aeolian sediment transport, storm-driven erosion, vegetation feedbacks, and barrier morphology, and was evaluated using historical observations from both regions. Controlled simulations varied initial beach width, sediment redistribution from dune erosion, vegetation characteristics, and storm frequency to assess their combined effects on dunes.
Simulations demonstrate the dominant control of beach width on the long-term evolution of dune state through its control of the availability of sediment for aeolian transport. The wider beaches have greater sediment supply and fetch length, which ease transport of sand to vegetated dunes and thus dune growth. By contrast, narrow beaches restrict the supply of sediment and favor transitional or low dune states. The degree of erosion and the recuperation of vegetation are governed by storminess, which in turn influences the stability of the dunes, particularly in areas where dunes were not present at the beginning.
Results show that variations in beach width and sediment supply may explain the contrasting dune states observed between Dutch and US barrier island systems. This study contributes to the understanding of the processes controlling long-term barrier island dune evolution by incorporating storms, vegetation, and morphological interactions within a single framework.