The development of environmentally compatible and low-cost substrates is important for coral reef restoration while reducing reliance on conventional cement-based materials. This study aimed to develop and comparatively evaluate waste-derived substrates as candidate materials for further coral restoration research. Three clay-bound substrate formulations were prepared using oyster shell powder (OST), conch shell–tile dust mixture (CTDT), and ceramic tile-squaring dust (TDT), with mixing ratios of 6:4, 3:2:5, and 6:4, respectively. The substrates were fired at 650 °C for oyster and conch shell-based formulations and 900 °C for the tile dust-based formulation. Water absorption, linear shrinkage, weight loss, and leachate characteristics were evaluated using replicate measurements. A seven-day preliminary marine deployment at Dikkowita Fishery Harbour was conducted to assess structural stability and early biological colonization. TDT recorded the lowest electrical conductivity (82.30 ± 0.98 µS cm⁻¹) and total suspended solids (56.00 ± 0.66 mg L⁻¹), indicating comparatively lower chemical and particulate release. It also showed approximately 80–100% green algal biofilm coverage after seven days. OST showed moderate algal growth and greater diversity of early colonizing organisms, while CTDT exhibited cracking and fragmentation. Overall, TDT showed the most favourable combined physicochemical, structural, and early colonization performance during the preliminary screening. However, the seven-day deployment and absence of direct coral settlement testing do not establish restoration suitability. Longer-term studies incorporating coral settlement, recruitment, survival, and growth are required to determine the applicability of the selected substrate for coral restoration.