Oceans cover nearly 70% of the Earth's surface and are home to enormous biological and chemical diversity. Purified marine compounds and/or complex bioactive mixtures can be used to create innovative products with potential pharmaceutical, nutraceutical, and other industrial applications. Currently, 14 marine drugs are approved on the market, including 9 for the treatment of cancer. Recently, there has been a renewed interest in marine habitat exploration, thanks in part to advances in sampling, cultivation, molecular biology, and bioinformatics. Attention is also increased for marine microorganisms, which are more easily cultivated than macroorganisms, allowing for a more environmentally friendly approach to study by avoiding the overexploitation of marine resources and the use of destructive harvesting practices. The remarkable biodiversity of microalgae in terms of species and metabolite production, as well as their ability to be cultivated in large quantities using eco-sustainable approaches, make them a valuable resource for molecule discovery. Extreme environments, such as polar regions, remain largely unexplored sources of marine natural products. The aim of this study was to evaluate the biological activity of 15 phytoplankton samples collected in different sites during the XXXIII Italian Antarctic Expedition (Mario Zucchelli Station, 2017–2018). Crude extracts were prepared by soaking the samples in methanol, followed by solvent evaporation. Extracts were screened for antiproliferative activity against human cancer cell lines at three concentrations for 24 hours of exposure. The effects were compared with those observed in normal human cell lines. Among the tested samples, extract 12A exhibited a dose-dependent antiproliferative activity against melanoma cells when compared to normal keratinocytes, indicating a selective effect toward tumor cells. It was able to reduce cell viability to about 50% at 10 μg/mL (p<0.001). This promising extract will be further investigated through additional chemical and molecular analyses.