Winter cooling and penetrative convection may initiate a dense shelf water cascade (DSWC), a key mechanism of cross-shelf exchange that facilitates the transfer of water masses, heat, and biogeochemical tracers from the ocean surface to the deep ocean. This study identifies and characterises a DSWC off the Faroe Shelf during the winter of 2009–2010. The existence of cascading on the Faroe Shelf has remained uncertain because strong tidal mixing homogenises the water column and typically inhibits the formation of dense near-bottom plumes. Here, we use a high-resolution ocean reanalysis to examine the complete life cycle of a cascading event, from preconditioning to decay. We show that during summer, tidal mixing generates lateral intrusions of mixed shelf water into the off-shelf thermocline. It also creates unfavourable preconditioning for cascading during the following winter by reducing the density of bottom shelf waters. Furthermore, tidal mixing weakens the wintertime shelf–open ocean density contrast through the entrainment of warmer ambient water. Nevertheless, intense winter cooling produces dense near-bottom water pools whose density exceeds that of the adjacent waters, allowing cascading to overcome the inhibiting effect of tidal mixing. The Faroe Shelf DSWC connects the surface layer with depths of approximately 200–400 m. Overall, these findings provide the first clear evidence of a DSWC on the Faroe Shelf and demonstrate that extreme atmospheric forcing can trigger cascading events despite the inhibiting influence of strong tidal mixing.