Introduction:
Offshore wind monopile foundations in shallow water are subject to severe breaking wave impact loads. The industry-standard Wienke-Oumeraci model represents this loading with a fixed curling factor (λ = 0.5), regardless of breaking wave type, and no published study has systematically compared Eulerian mesh-based and Lagrangian particle-based CFD methods for this problem against a common experimental benchmark.
Methods:
Two open-source CFD solvers, REEF3D (Level Set, Eulerian) and DualSPHysics (Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics, Lagrangian), were validated against large-scale wave flume (GWK, Hannover) experimental data for a D = 0.70 m cylinder on a 1:10 slope (H = 1.30 m, T = 4.0 s). REEF3D executed a 20-case parametric study spanning five breaker-location scenarios (A–E) across four wave heights. DualSPHysics underwent a three-resolution convergence study (dp = 0.10, 0.076, 0.065 m) using mDBC boundary treatment and Laminar+SPS viscosity, followed by targeted comparative runs bracketing pre-breaking and plunging scenarios.
Results:
Both solvers validated within 2% of the 12,800 N GWK reference force (REEF3D: −1.0%; DualSPHysics: −1.8%). Cross-method peak-force agreement was within 3% for the pre-breaking and at-breaking scenarios. Scenario-specific curling factors reduced peak-force mean absolute error by 84% relative to the fixed-λ standard. A previously unreported non-monotonic force behaviour was identified for downstream-breaking scenarios, driven by breaking-point migration on the sloped bathymetry with increasing wave height.
Conclusions:
This study provides the first systematic validation of REEF3D and DualSPHysics against a common experimental benchmark for breaking wave loads on cylindrical structures, demonstrating method-independent scenario-specific curling factors and providing dimensionless design guidance for offshore wind monopile foundations.