Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)-driven optimization has become a fundamental approach for improving the hydraulic performance of turbines; however, selecting appropriate CFD models, surrogate techniques, and metaheuristic algorithms remains largely dependent on engineering experience rather than standardized decision criteria. This study proposes an integrated decision-support framework for selecting computational strategies in multi-objective hydraulic turbine optimization based on hydraulic complexity, prediction accuracy, computational constraints, and optimization demand. Five normalized decision criteria are combined into a global complexity index that guides the selection of CFD fidelity, while additional decision indices determine the need for surrogate-assisted optimization and recommend suitable surrogate models and metaheuristic algorithms. The framework was calibrated using a database of 60 peer-reviewed CFD-based hydraulic turbine optimization studies and validated against an independent dataset comprising 25 published case studies covering different turbine technologies and optimization scenarios. Validation results demonstrated an overall agreement of 88% with published computational strategies, including 96% agreement for CFD model selection and surrogate model recommendation. The proposed methodology provides an objective and reproducible alternative to empirical computational strategy selection, reducing reliance on subjective engineering judgment while balancing numerical accuracy and computational cost. The framework represents a practical tool for supporting CFD-driven hydraulic turbine optimization and can be extended to other computationally intensive engineering applications involving complex fluid flow phenomena.