Urban drainage networks are typically designed to satisfy prescribed hydraulic constraints. However, their ability to accommodate additional hydraulic loading may vary depending on the constraints adopted during the design process. This study presents a systematic approach to evaluate the operational performance of optimized urban drainage networks by determining the flow-increase factor at which flooding first occurs.
The methodology considers optimized drainage network designs obtained under different maximum pipe filling ratios, while keeping all other hydraulic and design conditions unchanged. Each optimized configuration is then subjected to progressively increasing inflows to assess its hydraulic response beyond the design condition. The flow-increase factor (Qx), represents the multiplier applied to the design inflow and is used to identify the overflow threshold, defined as the point at which flooding first occurs. The assessment is conducted in two stages. First, a coarse search evaluates Qx values from 1.0 to 3.0 at intervals of 0.2 to identify the range in which flooding begins. A binary search is then performed within this range to determine the value of Qx associated with the onset of flooding with greater resolution.
This methodology is applied to urban drainage networks with different hydraulic and topographic characteristics. The results show that the maximum filling ratio imposed during design affects the additional hydraulic loading that the networks can accommodate before flooding begins. For the Chicó Sur network, reducing the maximum filling ratio from 93% to 50% increased the overflow threshold from approximately 1.07 to 2.13, corresponding to a 99% increase in the flow-increase factor, while the optimized network cost increased by only approximately 14.9%. The resulting flow-increase factors therefore reveal a trade-off between design cost and hydraulic capacity. The proposed framework provides an efficient and reproducible approach for comparing the hydraulic performance and flood onset conditions of optimized urban drainage configurations.