Air pockets trapped during pipeline emptying expand as water drains, generating sub-atmospheric pressures that can compromise pipe integrity. The Rigid Water Column (RWC) approach remains the standard tool for this transient because of its simplicity and low computational cost, while the Elastic Water Column (EWC) formulation additionally captures finite wave-propagation effects at greater computational cost. This work presents a detailed, run-by-run validation of an EWC formulation for pipeline emptying without air admission, together with a direct benchmark against the classical rigid-column approach, across twelve laboratory configurations from an inclined methacrylate pipeline: two pipe inclinations, three initial air-pocket lengths, and two downstream valve-opening schedules, each replicated twice.
For every configuration, computed and measured pressure-head time series are compared individually, and both the elastic and rigid formulations are benchmarked against the same experimental repetitions. Model accuracy is quantified as the mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of the minimum air-pocket pressure, averaged over all 24 experimental records. The elastic formulation reproduces minimum air-pocket pressure with a mean absolute error of 0.351%, while the rigid-column model achieves 0.353% — virtually identical, with the two models agreeing with each other to within 1 mm at worst. This closeness is consistent with the pipe's short acoustic period relative to its drainage timescale, which places the system in a quasi-rigid, mass-spring-like regime.
Under the investigated conditions, the rigid-column model therefore provides essentially the same prediction of the minimum air-pocket pressure as the elastic formulation, at substantially lower computational complexity. Presenting the complete run matrix, rather than aggregate statistics alone, further reveals where each formulation performs best and where small, localized effects introduce deviations from experimental behavior.