High-quality drinking water is becoming scarce due to contamination. Disinfection by-products (DBPs) are commonly formed in water treatment plants when disinfectants such as chlorine are used, leading to the formation of paraben-related DBPs (p-DBPs), which can impact human health more than their parent compounds. However, the scientific understanding of the impact of parabens and their p-DBPs on microbial communities is limited. The behaviour of single-species biofilms formed by S. maltophilia strains isolated from Portuguese DWDS on polyvinyl chloride (PVC) surfaces was evaluated following exposure to methylparaben (MP) and its disinfection by-product (DBP), 3,5-dichloromethylparaben (3,5-diCl-MP), at concentrations of 50 and 500 ng/L. Biofilms were characterised in terms of culturability, cell density, and extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) content by quantifying polysaccharides and proteins. While the MP remained largely inactive across several strains, its chlorinated derivative (3,5-diClMP) induced substantial increases in colony-forming units (CFUs) of exposed biofilms compared to those exposed to MP, up to 48,1% at 500 ng/L and up to 70,1% at 50 ng/L. Cell density of 3,5-diClMP-exposed biofilms also increased up to 51,3% at 50 ng/L when compared to the control and up to 82% at 500 ng/L. Additionally, chlorination of MP does not seem to enhance bacterial eradication. Exposure to 3,5-diClMP triggered a robust defensive phenotype characterised by a significant accumulation of EPS constituents, with sugar and protein contents increasing up to 74,4% at 500 ng/L and 57,7% at 50 ng/L. These chemical shifts were accompanied by strain-dependent structural alterations. At 50 ng/L, 3,5-diClMP increased biofilm thickness by up to 36.5%, while enhancing porosity up to 28.3% compared to MP. At 500 ng/L, roughness increased by up to 11.8%. Consequently, fluctuating parabens concentrations in water could favour resilient pathogens, change architectural biofilms by EPS enhancement, stabilise biofilms, and compromise drinking water safety.