The tank cascade system (TCS), Sri Lanka’s historical water networks of reservoirs, has played a crucial role in ensuring reliable water supplies particularly for paddy cultivation. Much academic attention has been paid to it in north central and northwestern regions, but its temporal-spatial distribution and governance of TCSs in Monaragala District remain unknown despite its importance to the national agricultural economy. To fill this gap, this study maps the spatial distribution and temporal changes of TCSs and examines their existing governance arrangement in Buttala DSD. A GIS-based mapping and DEM-based hydrological analysis were conducted using ArcMap 10.4.1 to identify and delineate the historical changes in locations and distributions of tank cascade systems. The identified information on maps was verified by conducting field observations and expert interviews. The results show a relatively high concentration of tanks in this DSD, with a tank density of one tank per 4.31 km² and 34 tank cascade systems. About 68% of the identified tanks remain functional today with an average of 4.72 tanks per cascade system. About 76% of the total paddy land extent is irrigated by tanks and anicuts, which are integral parts of the tank cascade system. This study also identified the extent to which formal institutional management and traditional practices coexist and how multiple stakeholders are involved. Our interviews with stakeholders found that persistent physical, financial, and institutional barriers hindered effective irrigation practices in Buttala. These finding highlights policy gaps in undertaking tank rehabilitation and local tank management.