On 21 January 2026, an extreme storm delivered over 125 mm of rainfall within three hours to the eastern suburbs of Athens, triggering a devastating flash flood in Ano Glyfada. Driven by rapid historical urbanization at the foot of Mount Hymettus and degraded natural retention capacity, the event caused severe infrastructure damage and highlighted the critical vulnerability of Mediterranean peri-urban catchments. This study presents a comparative hydrological modeling framework designed to evaluate the effectiveness of integrated Nature-Based Solutions (NbS) and Low Impact Development (LID) practices in mitigating extreme runoff hazards. Using a GIS-based event-based rainfall-runoff model, multiple spatial intervention scenarios are simulated and contrasted against the current unmitigated baseline state. Upstream interventions focus on hydromodification and catchment restoration through extensive afforestation, small check dams for flood peak attenuation, and wire-mesh debris traps for sediment retention. Downstream, urban-scale LID strategies incorporate high-permeability pavements, infiltration trenches, and green infrastructure with integrated rainwater harvesting systems. The modeling results quantify the relative efficiency of individual and combined mitigation scenarios across key hydrological metrics, including effective rainfall volume (Peff), peak discharge (Qpeak) and total flood volume (Vtotal). Preliminary comparative hydrographs indicate that holistic upstream-downstream integration significantly enhances soil infiltration, delays catchment response time, and substantially reduces peak flows along the small mountainous catchment area-urban transition zone. By evaluating multi-scale NbS-LID combinations under extreme rain, this work provides actionable hydro-meteorological insights and evidence-based guidelines for climate-resilient urban planning and flood risk reduction in vulnerable Mediterranean peri-urban environments.