Microplastic pollution represents a growing environmental threat to aquatic ecosystems. This study assessed the occurrence and chemical characterization of microplastics in twelve Mediterranean ponds located in the province of Jaén (Andalusia, Spain). The aim was to identify the microplastic pollution fingerprint, defined as the characteristic combination of polymers and pigments present in a given aquatic ecosystem. Water samples were collected from each pond; microplastics were isolated, identified via stereomicroscopic examination, and chemically characterized using Raman spectroscopy. Results revealed that each pond exhibited a distinct chemical composition, resulting in a unique microplastic pollution fingerprint that reflects the influence of local pollution sources and anthropogenic activities within the surrounding catchments. Furthermore, ponds subjected to higher anthropogenic pressure exhibited a greater diversity of pollutants compared to those less influenced by human activities, with identified polymers and pigments including polypropylene, polyethylene, PVC, polyester, phthalate blue, indigo, and ivory black. In addition, hydrological connectivity, retention times, and hydrodynamics dictate how microplastics disperse, directly altering ecosystem structure and functioning. Although direct toxicological effects were not measured, biological ingestion by local biota is strongly implied, risking food web transfer. Overall, chemical profiling proves essential for deepening the ecohydrological understanding of these Mediterranean wetlands, enabling accurate source tracing and informing effective conservation strategies.