Effective municipal solid waste (MSW) management is essential for achieving sustainable urban development, but a number of cities in sub-Saharan Africa are suffering from serious operational problems. In this study a mixed-methods approach—is made use of, involving a desk study, fieldwork, laboratory analysis and quantitative assessment—in order to examine the MSW management system in Anambra State, Nigeria, with a focus on Onitsha and Awka. The morphological characterisation shows that organic waste makes up the biggest portion (51.56%), then comes plastic (20.67%), followed by textiles (10.9%), metals (9.29%), bottles (4.5%) and other wastes (3.64%). Households are the main producers of waste, whereas institutions are the smallest contributors. Taking 2023 as the base year, the estimated volumes of MSW generated are 289,984,050 kg in Onitsha and 89,425,000 kg in Awka, thus providing the empirical basis for modelling future scenarios and for assessing possible optimisation routes. The laboratory analysis found Enterococcus faecalis and E. coli in all the samples, and in one sample lead (Pb) was found in amounts above the Maximum Permissible Concentration, which presents public health risks via direct contact, through leachate running off into water sources and by possible transfer into the food chain. The present system is experiencing a number of interrelated difficulties in the area of infrastructure (very poor roads, inadequate storage and collection facilities), in operations (lack of suitable technology, infrequent evacuation) and in relation to human factors (residents' non-compliance and low staff motivation). The key strategies for optimisation include public sensitisation campaigns, on-the-job training for staff, improvements to the infrastructure (such as additional covered trucks and automated collection), and better access to inner streets and suburbs. The results offer practical evidence for policymakers who wish to move from a reactive approach to waste disposal to the implementation of sustainable and integrated MSW management systems in the rapidly urbanising Nigerian cities.