Nature-based solutions for wastewater treatment are crucial for sustainable water management, particularly in semi-arid regions facing water scarcity. This study evaluates the long-term pollutant removal efficiency of two pilot-scale horizontal subsurface flow (HSSF) constructed wetlands (CWs) in Sicily, Italy, and assesses the agronomic impacts of reusing the treated effluent. Over a three-year period, treated wastewater (TWW) was used to irrigate bermudagrass (Cynodon dactylon (L.) Pers.) in a split-plot design, in comparison with freshwater (FW). Both CWs systems demonstrated highly effective, long-term removal of physico-chemical and microbiological contaminants. Maximum removal efficiencies reached 83% for COD, 81% for BOD5, 66% for total nitrogen, and 50% for total phosphorus. Agronomic evaluations revealed that TWW irrigation significantly enhanced plant performance due to its residual nutrient content. TWW-irrigated bermudagrass produced a higher average above-ground biomass (1358.74 kg ha-1) compared to the FW (1005.98 kg ha-1), while maintaining excellent visual turf quality. Soil analyses indicated that while pH levels remained stable, TWW-irrigated plots exhibited increased levels of organic matter and essential macronutrients, alongside expected rises in soil salinity and sodium. This research highlights the dual benefits of HSSF CWs in urban environment: they provide reliable, decentralized wastewater treatment and generate a nutrient-rich alternative water source. Reusing this effluent effectively reduces freshwater demand and the need for mineral fertilizers in urban landscaping, thereby advancing circular water management principles.