EventsThe 10th International Electronic Conference on Water Sciences
Published
This submission belongs to the session S9. Agricultural Water Systems of the event The 10th International Electronic Conference on Water Sciences
Published date
19 Nov, 2026
Academic Editor
author-avatarAthanasios Loukas
Citation
Rafael Olmos Ruiz, Plastic vs. Organic Mulching under Water Scarcity: Agronomic Performance and Economic Viability in Mediterranean Organic Lemon Production, in Proceedings of The 10th International Electronic Conference on Water Sciences, 24 November–27 November 2026, MDPI: Basel, Switzerland
Share
Email
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Plastic vs. Organic Mulching under Water Scarcity: Agronomic Performance and Economic Viability in Mediterranean Organic Lemon Production

1. Research Group in Agricultural Economics and Rural Development. Department of Applied Economics. University of Murcia, Espinardo Campus, Building 2, 30100 Murcia, Spain.
Abstract

Water scarcity is a defining constraint for irrigated citrus systems in semi-arid Mediterranean regions, where reduced allocations from surface transfers and increasing dependence on alternative sources are compressing both yields and profit margins. Agroecological soil management practices that reduce non-productive water losses and sustain soil functionality are therefore critical for the long-term viability of these systems under climate change.

This study evaluates plastic mulching (PM) and organic mulching derived from shredded pruning residues (OM) as adaptation strategies for organic lemon (Citrus × limon 'Fino') production in southeastern Spain. The trial was established on a clay loam soil, with soil homogeneity across experimental blocks verified before the study. Soil health indicators were taken from previous monitoring at the same site, where OM, compared with bare soil, increased total organic carbon by 25% and water-soluble organic carbon threefold, nearly doubled dehydrogenase activity, raised bacterial richness and diversity, kept summer soil moisture higher (8.8% vs 2.0%) and lowered root-zone temperature by about 2 °C. Four contrasting water-availability scenarios were defined based on current and projected allocations from the Tajo–Segura Water Transfer system, combining irrigation community supply, private wells, and desalinated water. Agronomic performance was assessed through fruit yield and water productivity, while economic feasibility was evaluated using net present value (NPV), internal rate of return (IRR), and apparent water productivity (AWP) over a 25-year lifecycle horizon.

Under water-restricted conditions, both mulching strategies were more efficient than bare soil management, maintaining high crop productivity with lower irrigation requirements. PM reduced the irrigation volume needed to reach maximum yield by approximately 12% relative to the control and achieved the highest water productivity. OM achieved the highest absolute yields under unrestricted scenarios, consistent with its positive effects on soil carbon, microbial activity and thermal regulation. Under severe water scarcity, the non-mulched system became economically unviable, whereas both mulching strategies maintained strongly positive returns.

These results show that mulching, particularly with locally generated organic residues, is a financially robust adaptation strategy for Mediterranean organic citrus systems facing increasing water stress, with clear benefits for soil health that should be confirmed through long-term monitoring.

Keywords
circular economy
climate adaptation
organic lemon
pruning residues
semi-arid Mediterranean
soil water conservation
Parcel Level Estimation of Subsurface Drain Spacing Using Hydrological Modelling and Geospatial Analysis
Growth, Yield and Agro-Morphological Responses of Pepper (Capsicum annuum) to Treated Greywater Irrigation in Akure, Nigeria