Natural load-bearing materials achieve high structural efficiency through the organization of constituents with different dimensions and functions across multiple scales. Inspired by this principle, this study investigates the combined use of fly ash and bottom ash as aluminosilicate precursors for the development of geopolymer materials intended for construction applications. Fly ash was progressively substituted with bottom ash at 0, 10, 20, 30, and 40 wt.%, while identical alkaline activation and curing conditions were maintained to isolate the effect of precursor proportion. Particular attention was given to the complementary contribution of the fine and relatively reactive fly ash particles and the coarser bottom ash fraction to the development of the geopolymer matrix. X-ray diffraction, Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy, and scanning electron microscopy were used to follow structural and microstructural changes, while density, water absorption, and compressive strength were evaluated as engineering performance indicators. An intermediate bottom ash incorporation of 20 wt.% resulted in the most favorable balance between matrix compactness and mechanical performance. The broader particle-size distribution promoted more efficient packing and reduced accessible porosity while preserving sufficient reactive aluminosilicate species for the formation of a continuous binding phase. Excessive bottom ash incorporation, however, increased the fraction of incompletely reacted particles and weakened matrix continuity. These findings show that binary fly ash–bottom ash geopolymers can be tailored through controlled precursor organization rather than relying exclusively on chemical composition. Such a hierarchical design strategy provides an interesting route toward resource-efficient geopolymer materials combining complementary industrial mineral fractions for construction applications.