Smallholder farmers often experience low yields that fluctuate yearly due to the variability of climate, resources, and diseases. The objective of the study was to assess cultivar x environment x management on potato yield stability. The experiments were conducted in five different environments (Mbalenhle, Hlathikhulu, Mbhava, Stezi, and Gobizembe) in KwaZulu-Natal (South Africa) for two consecutive seasons (2022/23 and 2023/24) at smallholder farming settings under rainfed open field conditions. Four selected potato cultivars (Mondial, Electra, Sababa, and Panamera) were planted in different management practices, which were two levels of mulch (non-mulch and mulch), and fungicides (sprayed and unsprayed) in a randomized complete block design. Analysis was conducted using Genotype and Genotype by Environment (GGE) biplot and Additive Main effects and Multiplicative Interaction (AMMI) models. The analysis of variance from AMMI revealed that the cultivar and environment interactions showed significant differences (P<0.05) under different management practices. A GGE and AMMI biplot graphically showed the inter-relationship between the tested environment and cultivars under different management practices. Mondial was more stable across management practices, except under mulched and unsprayed conditions, although a low yield was observed compared to Electra and Panamera. Electra was found to be stable and had high yield stability across all management practices and environments except Hlathikhulu due to its high tolerance against dry spells and foliar diseases such as late blight. At Hlathikhulu, Panamera was found to have a stable yield across different management practices. Smallholder farmers from Stezi, Mbalenhle, Mbhava, and Gobizembe can select Electra and apply the spraying of fungicides; in contrast, those from Hlathikhulu can use Panamera and fungicide spraying to obtain a potato yield with fewer fluctuations.