The increasing adoption of additive manufacturing (AM) in the production of high-performance metallic components highlights the critical need for rigorous quality control and inspection processes. While AM provides unparalleled design freedom and customization potential, concerns remain about the consistency of powder raw materials and the resulting mechanical properties of 3D-printed parts. This article examines these concerns through a case study focusing on 3D-printed metal components manufactured using the laser powder-bed fusion process, specifically with maraging steel. A demonstration maraging steel part is meticulously characterized across several dimensions: geometry, shape limitations, chemical composition, microstructure, surface roughness, and hardness. This comprehensive analysis evaluates material homogeneity, the impact of heat treatments, and the overall suitability of 3D-printed components as replacements for critical parts traditionally produced with conventional manufacturing techniques. The results indicate that 3D-printed maraging steel parts can indeed satisfy the stringent requirements of demanding applications where dimensional accuracy and structural integrity are non-negotiable. However, this paper emphasizes the importance of continued research and process optimization. Areas for improvement include refined powder quality control, optimized post-processing techniques, and deeper investigations into the long-term reliability of 3D-printed metallic components. Addressing these factors will further accelerate the adoption of AM across industries where performance and dependability are paramount.