The classification of Hydrobiidae Stimpson, 1865, a diverse family of freshwater gastropods, is hindered by their minute size and simplified shell morphology, resulting in a lack of diagnostic features in fossils. This leads to taxonomic ambiguities and the concealment of cryptic diversity, as seen in Horatia schlosseri (Royo-Gómez, 1922), a species frequently reassigned without consistent analysis. An integrative taxonomic approach is thus essential for accurate fossil identification and systematic resolution. To assess morphological variation within H. schlosseri, we applied geometric morphometrics (GM), analyzing shell shape across 163 specimens from eight Iberian localities. These included syntypes of H. schlosseri, type material of Horatia klecakiana (type species of Horatia), and paratypes of the similar genus Tarraconia. Shells were digitized with 18 landmarks/semi-landmarks and analyzed using Procrustes superimposition, Linear Discriminant Analysis (LDA), and ANOSIM.GM analysis revealed four distinct morphotypes within the H. schlosseri complex. Specimens from Alcalá del Júcar, previously attributed to H. schlosseri, clustered statistically with Tarraconia (ANOSIM p > 0.05) and were reassigned as Tarraconia sp. 1, further supported by the presence of a diagnostic varix. Two new cryptic species were also identified: Horatia sp. 1 (La Hontanilla Spring, Cuenca) and Horatia sp. 2 (Concud, Teruel), both from localities historically linked to H. schlosseri. Our results highlight the limitations of traditional morphological methods in Hydrobiidae systematics and emphasize the value of GM in revealing cryptic diversity. This study underscores the need for a comprehensive revision of Iberian caenogastropod fossils using integrative, quantitative approaches.